According to this blog’s WordPress stats, the majority of search results that lead people to Pop Goes the Librarian categorize the profession as solely female. How do I know that?
- “hot librarian” : 37 views
- “hot librarians” : 23 views
- “hot lady librarians” : 15 views
- “librarian chic” : 5 views
- “smokin hot librarian” : 2 views
The list goes. Although “hot” isn’t exactly a gendered qualifier, when followed by the word “librarian” it might as well be. It’s fairly obvious to those of us who work in libraries that men are the minority. According to the article “Male Librarians: Gender Issues and Stereotypes“, “Without question the Library profession is female-dominated. Decade after decade the ratio of female to male librarians remains roughly 4:1, although the mix is closer to 3:1 in academic libraries.” This ratio rings true for my own library; out of the 16 professional librarians we employ, only six are men.
So when we consider the main male librarian stereotype, what comes to mind? First we have the Mean Librarian. The horrible, no good reference librarian from Sophie’s Choice, for example, perfectly illustrates why librarians are so mean. There’s also the highly amusing Conan the Librarian, who isn’t afraid to tell us what is best in life.
In many ways this figure closely resembles the Spinster Librarian image in popular culture: intelligent, introverted, socially awkward, academic to a fault, asexual, unmarried, be-speckled, etc. Think Rupert Giles from the early seasons of Buffy the Vampire Slayer; adorable in his tweed blazer, but largely socially inept and certainly hopeless in the love department. The fact that he’s British, prim, and mostly unskilled at slaying vamps (again, we’re talking seasons 1-2 of Buffy) only exaggerate his emasculated characteristics. However, a woman being written/portrayed as asexual is one thing – poor girl, so sad, but maybe she’ll find her prince charming one day? (*cough* Marian did *cough*) On the other hand, an asexual man in a largely female-dominant profession can only mean one thing: he’s gay.
Male teachers (K-12), male nurses, and male librarians all share the common thread that there’s something wrong with them, simply because they’re men working in a woman’s world. Who in their right (heterosexual) mind would do that? The term “male nurse” is just as sexist as “guybrarian” is, simply because it creates a distinction based on gender. Etymologically speaking, “nurse” and “librarian” are not inherently female terms, but we tend to recognize them as just that simply because of what we’re exposed to. After all, most nurses and librarians are women. Remember Meet the Parents, in which Robert De Niro’s uber male character constantly reminds his future son-in-law of the fact that he’s a male nurse? He’s doing the work of a woman, so obviously he’s unworthy.
I’m obviously speaking as a woman, so it’s best not to get too political here. I will say that the term “guybrarian” does seem to set teeth on edge, if only because it creates a cutesy distinction where one isn’t needed. When we think of pop culture, however, the male librarian figure isn’t nearly as prominent as the various female representations. My favorite librarian in literature (Lucian from Neil Gaiman‘s Sandman series) admittedly fits the guybrarian stereotype perfectly – but, alas, I’m saving him for another post. But who else is there? Are there any other librarians-who-just-so-happen-to-be-men in popular culture who fit the stereotype? Which ones buck the trend?